Original Archive Back to the project

The 2012 file, as it was

Source material for the Student Innovation Project. The research paper below is reproduced in full from the original submission, unedited. Nothing here has been modernized.

Non-Static Biometric Identification — a device that, using random intensity light patterns, produces a unique image of the fingertip
Christopher Johnson — project manager, programmer, network security
Olena Burnes — programmer, network security
Project dates 11 October 2012 to 30 December 2013 · University of Advancing Technology
Primary document · Week 4 submission

The research paper

Abstract

In the era of growing digital society cybercrimes threaten individual as well as organizational information, assets, and identity. Instant and secure personal identification is crucially important in controlling access to computer systems. Existing biometric identification systems increase the security of computer systems. However, numerous inadequacies compromise the main purpose of such devices. Existing biometric identifiers are static.

The main goal of this project is to create a device to capture a non-static biometric identifier for the purpose of authentication. The innovative component of this project is the use of light patterns at varied intensity applied to fingertip in order to produce an image. The end result is a non-static biometric identifier.

Each pass through the scanner is random and the image created for comparison is dynamic. Traditional physiological biometrics compare a static image to a static template in order to confirm or deny match. This makes them more susceptible for spoofing. Spoof resistance is one of the key benefits to our non-static biometric identifier.

Keywords

Biometrics · identifier · automated biometric identification system · biometric data · biometric algorithm · common biometric exchange file format · one-to-one · one-to-many · verification · software · hardware · image recognition · network security · digital image · digital camera · facial features recognition · fingerprints · iris · retina · static · non-static

Background and prior art

Definition

The term biometrics derives from two Greek words, bio meaning life and metrics meaning measure. Biometrics is a technological and scientific authentication method based on biology and used in information assurance, authenticating secure entry, data or access via human biological information such as DNA or fingerprints.

Rajan describes biometrics, or life measurement, as the use of unique physical features such as fingerprints, facial features, retina or iris to identify an individual. A concise definition is the automatic recognition of a person using distinguishing traits. A more expansive definition is any automatically measurable, robust and distinctive physical characteristic or personal trait that can be used to identify an individual or verify a claimed identity. The most important application of biometrics is security.

History

The history of biometrics traces to prehistoric times, when cavemen signed their drawings with their handprints. In Babylon two thousand years ago fingerprints were used for business transactions. In China fingerprints were in use from the fourteenth century.

The first fingerprint identification system was developed in the eighteenth century by Azizul Haque for Edward Henry, then Inspector General in India. Henry assigned a numerical value to each individual finger, beginning with the right thumb and ending with the left pinky, and grouped fingerprint records by pattern type — arch, whorl, and loop. Henry's system was used successfully by law enforcement agencies around the world.

In 1969 the FBI contracted the National Institute of Standards and Technology to develop a system automating fingerprint identification. The first device for hand identification was invented and patented by David Sidlauskas in 1988. Since then new technologies have been developed and commercialized for authentication, providing secure access to computer networks.

Application

To authenticate a network user's identity, biometric characteristics are used such as fingerprints, iris, facial features, voice, DNA, behavioral patterns, and combinations of these. This method is more reliable and safe than traditional password and PIN based methods, which can be stolen or copied. The physical presence of the authorized user is required at the time of identification.

Biometric identification devices are widely applied in corporate, governmental and military settings. Such devices usually consist of a scanner or video camera as biometric input, software that translates biometric information into digital form and indexes or compares it against existing information, and a database of stored biometric information.

Attributes and features

A biometric system is essentially a pattern recognition system which makes a personal identification by determining the authenticity of a specific physical or behavioral characteristic possessed by the user. Biometric technologies are defined as automated methods of identifying or authenticating the identity of a living person based on a physical or behavioral characteristic.

The biometric system connects an event to a single person, whereas other forms of identification, such as a personal identification number, may be used by anyone.

The biometric identifier has two modules, a Database Preparation Module and a Verification Module. The Database Preparation Module consists of an Enroll Module and a Training Module. The Verification Module comprises a Matching Module and a Decision Module.

Components

  • A silicon sensor that reads data
  • A capacitance that determines the pattern of ridges and valleys at any point during a cycle of charging and discharging the capacitor array
  • Data scanned and converted by software into digital format
  • A map of unique finger characteristics created on the basis of minutia detection
  • A biometric template developing signal processing algorithms
  • Templates compared against encrypted data storage
  • A decision process that uses matching results to allow or deny access

Strengths of existing identifiers

  1. They meet most of the ASTM conceptual characteristics
  2. They have the potential to identify a person with a high accuracy rate
  3. Biometric tools are difficult to duplicate or steal
  4. Application increases overall security
  5. A user is identified by his or her own unique parameters
  6. Non-repudiation of transactions confirmed biometrically
  7. Users cannot share access rights
  8. Prevents use of stolen or lost identifiers
  9. Optimizes administration
  10. Reduces access time and eliminates password typing errors, damage or loss of identifiers
  11. Increases system administrator productivity
  12. Reduces expenses related to administration of access infrastructure
  13. Easy to use, with no passwords to memorize, type or change
  14. Requires one-time enrollment
  15. Provides quick authorization, user convenience and workflow efficiency

Weaknesses of existing identifiers

  1. Identification requires special equipment, software and expertise
  2. The identification process is time consuming and can affect user performance
  3. It requires special technology infrastructure and administration
  4. Existing devices carry high cost of purchase, adjustment and maintenance
  5. Existing systems require data templates of many thousands of bytes, expensive storage media, and slower processing

Potential challenges

  1. Insertion of the missing components and characteristics
  2. Proximity and dynamics measurement
  3. Potential threat of violation of an individual's privacy
  4. Cost
  5. Timelines

Project description and innovation claim

As Richards pointed out, some of the most important factors necessary for any effective biometric system are accuracy, speed and throughput rate, acceptability to users, uniqueness of the biometric organ and action, resistance to counterfeiting, reliability, data storage requirements, enrollment time, intrusiveness of data collection, and subject and system contact requirements.

The attempt was made to create a device to capture a non-static biometric identifier for the purpose of authentication. The innovative component of this project is the use of light patterns at varied intensity applied to the fingertip in order to produce an image. The end result is a non-static biometric identifier. Each pass through the scanner is random and the image created for comparison is dynamic.

In order to create the prototype, an Arduino microprocessor controller, high intensity LED lights, a TTL JPEG camera board, an IR proximity sensor, a small project box and a PC to receive and process image data are used. Each device must be coded in order to function properly. For the purpose of this sprint, we have attempted to achieve base functionality in using the device to capture images to the PC.

The LED light bed will be used to produce the random intensity light patterns. For convenience and automation, the IR proximity sensor will have a range value in order to detect a finger being present in the scanner. This will act as the trigger for the device. Once triggered, Processing code on the PC side will send information needed for producing light patterns, send capture commands to the camera, and receive serial data to capture images for processing.

Usage scenario

  1. Enrollment. The user places a finger into the device.
  2. An LED matrix produces a random pattern of light on the finger at various intensities.
  3. The TTL JPEG camera captures an image and sends it to a PC for processing.
  4. The image either matches one of the registered users' base images in specified values known only to the machine.
  5. If valid, a known identity can be determined.
  6. Unknown scans could prompt for registration with the proper credentials to do so.
  7. Training. The user receives instruction for secure application of the device.

Evaluation criteria

Functional characteristics

Accessibility. This system requires the establishment of a local distributing mechanism for the identifier and a central administration to manage its organizational scope.

Assignability. The physical presence and cooperation of an individual, and the necessary tools and equipment, must be present and functional.

Identification. The physical characteristics of the user can be matched with characteristics stored in the database, supplemented where needed by additional information.

Verification. Verification of the identifier will depend on the computer algorithm and equipment used.

Merge and split. Duplicate identifiers can be merged via cross-reference. An identifier issued to more than one individual can be handled by issuing new identifiers.

Design characteristics

Uniqueness. The information contained in the biometric identifier is unique.

Repository-based. The identification system is supplemented by other demographic information.

Concise. Digitized images smaller than a face require less storage.

Unambiguous. Other than an individual's feature images, the identifier is not conducive to manual processing or recognition.

Networked. The device can be supported by computer networks.

Project logic model

Goal

To create a device to capture a non-static biometric identifier based on random light intensity images of the fingertip, for verification and authentication.

Objectives

  • Behavioral. Simplify user-device interaction with new software and hardware that eliminates steps existing devices require, and design reliable, low maintenance access.
  • Performance. Increase security, accuracy and reliability by using random intensity light patterns to produce a unique image of the fingertip.
  • Process. Design a non-static identifier that provides network access only during the physical presence of a user.
  • Product. Change the appearance of the existing device, making it more aesthetic and high tech.
  • Transference. Expand application of the product across a variety of settings.

Description of design prototype

The prototype will use an Arduino Uno R3 microcontroller, a TTL camera sensor, an IR proximity sensor, an LED matrix, a shift register for the LED array and the LCD, and a small project box to house the circuits with an opening for finger insertion. The current prototype focuses on random patterns of light at various intensities to produce a non-static biometric identifier.

References as cited in 2012

ASTM International · Biometric History, biometrics.gov · Gompers, J. (2003), Biometrics, The Basics · Lerner, E. (2011), Biometric Identification · Rajan, V. (2011), What Is Biometrics · Richards, D. (2010), Biometric Identification · Rutter, J. (2012), Biometric Tools Used for Network Security · Technopedia · Sidlauskas, D., US Patent 4,736,203, 3D hand profile identification apparatus, 5 April 1988 · Woodward, Horn and Gatune (2003), Biometrics · Woodward, Orlans and Higgins (2003), Biometrics, McGraw Hill

Secondary document

From the pitch script

Written for the project video. This is where the earlier name of the project appears, and where the limitation that drove the whole pivot is stated out loud.

Snowflake incorporates all of these elements except being dynamic. We currently are exploring ways to modify these static identifiers in order to produce a dynamic non-static biometric identification device.
The holy grail of network security is 100% accurate and valid real-time identification coupled with a proximity method to ensure the authorized end user is the only one accessing the network and workstation.

The same script notes that an attacker could use a 3D printer to produce a model of a hand that would defeat a hand-shape scanner. Written in 2012, when consumer 3D printing barely existed.

Plates

Plates from the folder

The concept drawings first, then the poster, then the bench and the screen. The Rev 1 drawing at the top is the project before it became non-static.

snowflake · conceptual drawing rev 1 · october 2012
snowflake · conceptual drawing rev 1 · october 2012The original project, before the pivot. LED and infrared emitters above the fingertip. A camera sensor reading the vein pattern, a pulse oximeter light sensor establishing proof of life, and capacitance scanner plates capturing the fingerprint image. Artery and vein are labelled on the finger itself. Three biometric modalities and a liveness check in one enclosure.
biometric wrist strap · block diagram
biometric wrist strap · block diagramThe second factor. A random PIN communicated to the user as a sequence of vibrations in a wrist strap, entered on a Dynamic 10-Key whose digits do not hold fixed positions. The note adds that the strap could also house a kill switch proximity device.
ear kill switch · concept
ear kill switch · conceptA pulse oximeter worn on the ear, wired through the biometric device to the workstation. Continuous proof of life rather than a single check at login, with the session dropping when the user does.
bench · november 2012
bench · november 2012The TTL camera module still in its parts box. The LED matrix wired on a breadboard beside an Arduino Uno, resistor bandoliers and component bags across the desk. On the monitor, the Arduino IDE and a Logitech C310 capture window.
Non-static Biometric Identification conference poster, 2012
sip poster 2 · November 2012Introduction, objectives, primary innovation, secondary innovation, next steps and conclusion. Includes the Rev 2 capture device diagram, breadboard photographs of the LED matrix, and the block diagram for the biometric wrist strap.
Processing sketch, first capture test, November 2012
early code test · 7.59am, 7 november 2012Processing 2.0b5. The sketch is named First_attempt_capture_pixel_comparison. It declares two images, statImage and curImage, and reads frames from a Logitech HD Webcam C310 — the concept being proved before the TTL camera board arrived.

The panel headed Secondary Innovation is the part that never reached the research paper. It proposes a second authentication mechanism using the sense of touch — a system that communicates a random PIN to the user by sending a sequence of vibrations to a wrist strap, paired with a Dynamic 10-Key whose digits are not in fixed positions.

That is an out-of-band second factor delivered over a haptic channel, combined with a randomized keypad layout to defeat shoulder surfing. The block diagram notes the strap could also house a kill switch proximity device. Written in 2012, before smartwatches existed as a consumer category.

Source

The first sketch

Dated 31 October 2012. Twenty lines. Read a switch, light an LED. This is the whole file, and it is where a man who had never touched a microcontroller started, three weeks before the prototype captured an image.

int switchPin = 8;
int ledPin = 13;

void setup()
{
  pinMode(switchPin, INPUT);
  pinMode(ledPin, OUTPUT);
}

void loop()
{
  if(digitalRead(switchPin) == HIGH)
  {
    digitalWrite(ledPin, HIGH);
  }
  else
  {
   digitalWrite(ledPin, LOW);
  }
}

Filename sketch_oct31a.ino — the default name the Arduino IDE gives a new sketch on the thirty first of October. He never renamed it.

Contents

What is in the original folder

Every file, as it sits today, with its original modification date. Highlighted rows are the ones worth opening first.

FileTypeModified
Documents
Project Christopher_Johnson_Olena_Burnes_text-1.docxResearch paper2012-11-07
SIP_Pitch-Teleprompter.pptxPitch script2012-10-27
SIP_Sprint-Teleprompter.pptxSprint script2012-10-31
Thinking Hats.pptxSix Thinking Hats exercise2012-11-01
Presentation_Olena_Burnes.pptxTeam presentation2012-10-24
Posters
sip poster.pptConference poster, source2012-11-09
sip poster 2.pngConference poster, export2012-11-09
sip poster 3.pngConference poster, export2013-01-23
sip poster 2.pptConference poster, source2013-01-23
Hardware and circuits
IMG_0011.JPG to IMG_0015.JPGPrototype photographs2012-11-08
Virtual Bread Board.PNGCircuit simulation2012-11-01
New Drawing.PNGConcept drawing2012-11-02
photo.JPGBench photograph2012-11-02
Wrist Strap.jpg / .sdrEnclosure concept2012-10-26
Software and testing
Early_code_test.PNGFirst working capture2012-11-07
Current Software Tests.PNGTest output2012-11-08
Capture.PNGCapture output2012-10-22
processing-2.0b5-windows64.zipThe exact Processing build used2012-10-31
Concept and reference
Snowflake.jpgThe original project name2012-10-24
weakness.jpgResearch reference2012-10-26
EarKillSwitch.jpgResearch reference2012-10-25
Media
Video 1.wmaPresentation recording, 213 MB2012-10-26

The Processing 2.0b5 archive is the detail most people would delete. It means the exact toolchain that produced the original captures is still sitting in the folder, fourteen years later, next to the code it compiled.